Forensic Pathology
Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada · 1.1 · 29 EPAs
Also available in French.
Every EPA in the published guide, shown as the form DebriefMD fills in, with its fields and answer options.
Transition to Discipline
TTD-1
Performing pre-autopsy assessments
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 2.2 Synthesize case information to develop a differential diagnosis
- ME 2.2 Select procedures based on a differential diagnosis
- ME 2.3 Confirm identification of the deceased
- ME 3.2 Ensure legal authorization for autopsy has been obtained
Communicator
- COM 1.5 Apply knowledge of cultural and religious accommodations in scheduling and techniques for post-mortem exams and death investigations ensuring that the death investigation is not compromised
- COM 2.1 Integrate and summarize information obtained from the case file
- COM 2.1 Seek and synthesize information from other sources
Scholar
- S 3.1 Recognize uncertainty and knowledge gaps in professional encounters relevant to Forensic Pathology
Professional
- P 1.1 Complete assigned responsibilities
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTD-2
Performing autopsies
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply a broad base and depth of knowledge in clinical and biomedical sciences in autopsy pathology
- ME 1.3 Demonstrate awareness of relevant laws and regulations in relation to tissue/organ procurement, tissue retention, principles of consent, privacy and confidentiality
- ME 2.5 Perform external examination of the body
- ME 2.5 Perform evisceration of organs and gross dissection
- ME 2.5 Recognize and describe evidence of disease and/or injury
- ME 3.4 Obtain appropriate samples
Collaborator
- COL 1.2 Work effectively with autopsy room staff, directing their assistance during autopsy procedures
- COL 2.1 Convey information respectfully
Leader
- L 1.2 Apply the principles of laboratory safety and universal precautions
Professional
- P 1.1 Complete assigned responsibilities
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTD-3
Preparing autopsy reports in uncomplicated cases
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply a broad base and depth of knowledge in clinical and biomedical sciences in autopsy pathology
- ME 1.6 Recognize limits of own expertise and seek assistance
- ME 2.2 Interpret results of investigations based on differential diagnoses
- ME 2.5 Prepare written descriptions of the external, internal and microscopic findings
- ME 2.5 Interpret post-mortem findings in light of the clinical history and/or scene investigation and appreciate potential limitations of such interpretations
Communicator
- COM 4.1 Organize information in appropriate sections within a written, electronic or other digital record
- COM 4.1 Document autopsy procedure, sampling, and findings using a standard format and including all relevant information
- COM 4.1 Document medical reasoning and rationale for opinion
- COM 4.1 Document autopsy findings in an accurate, complete and timely manner and in compliance with legal and privacy requirements
Professional
- P 1.1 Complete assigned responsibilities
- P 4.2 Recognize evolving professional identity transitions and manage inherent stresses
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
Foundations
F-1
Interpreting the circumstances of the case
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 2.2 Interpret and evaluate information collected at the death scene including but not limited to health history, social information, and circumstances of death
- ME 2.2 Synthesize case information to develop a differential diagnosis
- ME 2.2 Select procedures based on a differential diagnosis
- ME 2.2 Describe the conditions under which a death is considered suspicious
- ME 2.5 Review the death scene information and clinical history in routine cases
- ME 3.2 Determine whether jurisdictional authorization applies
Communicator
- COM 2.1 Seek and synthesize relevant information from other sources, including the stakeholders, law enforcement personnel, and the medico- legal team
- COM 2.1 Integrate and summarize information obtained from the case file
Collaborator
- COL 1.1 Receive and appropriately respond to input from other medico-legal professionals
Professional
- P 1.1 Independently manage specialty-specific issues surrounding confidentiality, intervening when confidentiality is breached
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
F-2
Performing dissections including: open the calvarium; layered anterior neck with tongue removal; layered ante…
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of anatomy and physiology
- ME 2.5 Recognize and describe evidence of natural disease and/or injury
- ME 3.1 Integrate all sources of information to develop a procedural plan that is safe, and considers the risks and benefits of all approaches
- ME 3.1 Recognize indications for performing procedures
- ME 3.4 Perform common procedures in a skillful, fluid, and safe manner with minimal assistance
- ME 3.4 Seek assistance as needed when unanticipated findings or changing circumstances are encountered
Leader
- L 1.2 Apply the principles of laboratory safety and universal precautions consistently
Scholar
- S 3.1 Recognize uncertainty and knowledge gaps in clinical and other professional encounters relevant to Forensic Pathology
Professional
- P 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
- P 4.1 Manage the impact of physical and environmental factors on performance
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
F-3
Performing forensic autopsies of routine cases (adult and older child, non- suspicious injuries, suicide, sud…
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- Part A: ME 1.3 Apply clinical and biomedical sciences to Forensic Pathology
- Part A: ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of anatomy and physiology
- Part A: ME 2.5 Perform examination of tissue microscopically and review of toxicology or other ancillary test results where appropriate in routine cases
- Part A: ME 2.5 Identify the circumstances when toxicological and other ancillary investigations/tests may be appropriate for routine cases, and apply the procedures for sampling tissues, fluids and other evidence for these additional investigations
- Part A: ME 2.6 Take or organize satisfactory external, gross and microscopic photographs of the post- mortem examination and any relevant tissues
- Part A: ME 3.4 Seek assistance as needed when unanticipated findings or changing circumstances are encountered
- Part B: ME 2.5 Prepare written descriptions of the findings in routine cases
- Part B: ME 2.5 Formulate conclusions regarding mechanism, cause and manner of death in routine cases
Communicator
- Part A: COM 2.1 Seek and synthesize relevant information from sources, including the stakeholders, law enforcement personnel and medico-legal team
- Part B: COM 4.1 Summarize and convey autopsy findings in a written and oral fashion appropriate to the audience
Collaborator
- Part A: COL 1.1 Receive and appropriately respond to input from other medico-legal professionals
- Part A: COL 2.2 Communicate clearly and directly to promote understanding, manage differences, and resolve conflicts
Leader
- Part A: L 2.1 Consider costs when choosing case management options
- Part A: L 2.2 Apply evidence and guidelines with respect to resource utilization in common scenarios
Professional
- Part A: P 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
F-4
Preparing forensic pathology reports, including opinions, of routine cases
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply clinical and biomedical sciences to Forensic Pathology
- ME 1.6 Recognize the limitations of time of death determination in a post-mortem exam
- ME 2.5 Review the death scene information and clinical history in routine cases
- ME 2.4 Perform examination of tissues microscopically and review of toxicology or other ancillary test results where appropriate in routine cases
- ME 2.5 Prepare written descriptions of the findings in routine cases
- ME 2.5 Interpret post-mortem findings in light of the clinical history and/or scene investigation and appreciate potential limitations of such interpretations
- ME 3.4 Seek assistance as needed when unanticipated findings or changing circumstances are encountered
- ME 4.1 Ensure follow-up on results of investigation and ancillary testing
Communicator
- COM 4.1 Document information about decedent and their medical conditions in a manner that enhances death investigation
- COM 4.1 Document death investigation to adequately support conclusions and with adequate detail to allow independent review
- COM 4.1 Summarize and convey autopsy findings in an written and oral fashion appropriate to the audience
Health Advocate
- HA 1.1 Work with the family to identify opportunities for disease prevention, health promotion, and health protection
- HA 1.1 Identify hereditary diseases and inform family members to protect the health of living relatives
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
F-5
Delivering preliminary autopsy information to a variety of audiences
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Demonstrate awareness of relevant laws and regulations in relation to tissue/organ procurement, tissue retention, principles of consent, privacy and confidentiality
- ME 1.6 Recognize the limitations of time of death determination in a post-mortem exam
- ME 2.5 Interpret post-mortem findings in light of the clinical history and/or scene investigation and appreciate potential limitations of such interpretations
Communicator
- COM 1.1 Communicate using an approach that facilitates trust and autonomy and is characterized by empathy, respect, and compassion
- COM 1.4 Recognize when strong emotions (such as anger, fear, anxiety, or sadness) are impacting an interaction and respond appropriately
- COM 2.1 Integrate, summarize, and present the information obtained from a death investigation
- COM 3.1 Discuss with the stakeholders and family the degree of uncertainty inherent in all ongoing pending investigations
Collaborator
- COL 1.1 Receive and appropriately respond to input from other medico-legal professionals
Scholar
- S 3.1 Recognize uncertainty and knowledge gaps in professional encounters relevant to Forensic Pathology
Professional
- P 1.1 Independently manage specialty-specific issues surrounding confidentiality, intervening when confidentiality is breached
- P 1.2 Demonstrate an appreciation of the limitations of findings, individual professional limits and the necessity of seeking appropriate second opinions
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
F-6
Managing cases within the standards of timelines and resource stewardship
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 2.1 Iteratively establish priorities
- ME 4.1 Ensure follow-up on results of investigation and ancillary testing
Collaborator
- COL 1.1 Receive and appropriately respond to input from other medico-legal professionals
- COL 2.1 Delegate tasks and responsibilities in an appropriate and respectful manner
Leader
- L 1.2 Apply the principles of laboratory safety and universal precautions consistently
- L 2.2 Apply evidence and guidelines with respect to resource utilization in common scenarios
- L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Professional
- P 1.1 Complete assigned responsibilities
- P 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
- P 4.1 Demonstrate an ability to regulate attention, emotions, thoughts, and behaviours while maintaining capacity to perform professional tasks
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
Core
C-1
Providing case management of the scene
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.6 Describe the information and limitations pathology can provide in a given situation including but not limited to time of death determination
- ME 2.2 Focus the death investigation, performing it in a time-effective manner, without excluding key elements
- ME 2.2 Recognize the conditions under which a death is considered suspicious and manage appropriately
- ME 2.2 Collect and preserve evidence from a death scene, including photographs
- ME 2.2 Examine the body
- ME 2.2 Assess a death scene based on information provided by investigators
- ME 5.1 Prevent contamination of the death scene
Communicator
- COM 4.1 Adapt record keeping to the specific guidelines of Forensic Pathology and the medico-legal context
- COM 4.3 Share information with stakeholders and others in a manner that respects privacy and confidentiality and enhances understanding
Collaborator
- COL 1.3 Communicate effectively with physicians and other colleagues in the medico-legal team
Leader
- L 1.2 Actively encourage all involved in death investigation, regardless of their role, to report and respond to unsafe situations
- L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-2
Confirming the identity of the deceased
Key features and assessment plan
- This EPA focuses on the variety of methods available to confirm the identity of the deceased. - The case used to observe this EPA must require methodologies other than visual identification.
Case discussion by supervisor Use Form 1. Form must collect information on: - Identification: visual; other Collect 1 observation of achievement - At least 1 case that needed methodologies other than visual
Suggested observations: 1
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the principles of the various fields of forensic sciences, including toxicology, chemistry, biology (including DNA testing), firearm and tool mark examination, entomology, forensic photography, blood pattern analysis, fingerprint analysis, trace evidence and alternative light source examinations
- ME 2.3 Assess the adequacy of current identification of the deceased
- ME 4.1 Determine the necessity and appropriate timing of consultation
- ME 2.3 Establish identification, with consultation where appropriate
Communicator
- COM 2.1 Seek and synthesize relevant information from sources, including the stakeholders, law enforcement personnel and medico-legal team
Professional
- P 1.2 Demonstrate an appreciation of the limitations of findings, individual professional limitations and the necessity of seeking appropriate second opinions
- P 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-3
Performing special dissections including: face; eye; middle ear; posterior neck; vertebral artery; layered po…
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.6 Seek assistance in situations that are complex or new
- ME 3.1 Integrate planned procedures into global assessment and management plans
- ME 3.1 Recognize indications for performing special dissections
- ME 3.3 Triage a procedure, taking into account available resources
- ME 3.4 Competently perform discipline-specific dissections
- ME 3.4 Recognize and interpret findings
- ME 3.4 Document procedures accurately
Professional
- P 1.1 Inform funeral home personnel when special dissections or artefacts of post- mortem examination may require special handling
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-4
Performing forensic autopsies in pediatric cases
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- Part A: ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the principles of the various fields of forensic sciences, including toxicology, chemistry, biology (including DNA testing), firearm and tool mark examination, entomology, forensic photography, blood pattern analysis, fingerprint analysis, trace evidence and alternative light source examinations
- Part A: ME 2.5 Review the death scene information and clinical history in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part A: ME 2.5 Perform examination of tissues microscopically and review toxicology or other ancillary test results where appropriate in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part A: ME 2.6 Take or organize satisfactory external, gross and microscopic photographs of the post- mortem examination and any relevant tissues
- Part A: ME 3.4 Perform procedures in a skillful and safe manner, adapting to unanticipated findings or changing circumstances
- Part A: ME 4.1 Recognize the need for consultations, including but not limited to neuropathology, cardiovascular pathology, forensic anthropology and/or forensic odontology, and appropriately retain specimens
- Part A: ME 3.4 Seek assistance as needed when unanticipated findings or changing clinical circumstances are encountered
- Part B: ME 2.5 Prepare written descriptions of the external, internal and microscopic findings in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part B: ME 3.4 Document procedures accurately 3 COM 4.3Communicate information appropriately, including evidence-informed opinions and conclusions, to law enforcement personnel, coroners/medical examiners, and lawyers
Communicator
- Part A: COM 1.5 Apply knowledge of cultural and religious accommodations in scheduling and techniques for post-mortem exams and death investigations ensuring that the death investigation is not compromised
Leader
- Part A: L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Professional
- Part A: P 3.1 Fulfil the requirements of the physician’s duty to report, including communicable disease and suspected child abuse
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-5
Performing forensic autopsies of complex cases (homicides, criminally suspicious, complex medical, bodies rec…
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- Part A: ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the principles of the various fields of forensic sciences, including toxicology, chemistry, biology (including DNA testing), firearm and tool mark examination, entomology, forensic photography, blood pattern analysis, fingerprint analysis, trace evidence and alternative light source examinations
- Part A: ME 1.3 Demonstrate understanding of sections of the Canadian Criminal Code relevant to Forensic Pathology
- Part A: ME 2.2 Select and interpret appropriate procedures based on information available
- Part A: ME 2.5 Review the death scene information and clinical history in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part A: ME 2.6 Take or organize satisfactory external, gross and microscopic photographs of the post- mortem examination and any relevant tissues
- Part A: ME 3.4 Seek assistance as needed when unanticipated findings or changing clinical circumstances are encountered
- Part A: ME 4.1 Recognize the need for consultations, including but not limited to neuropathology, cardiovascular pathology, forensic anthropology and/or forensic odontology, and appropriately retain specimens
- Part B: ME 2.5 Perform examination of tissue microscopically and review toxicology or other ancillary test results in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part B: ME 2.5 Prepare written descriptions of findings in complex and/or pediatric cases
- Part B: ME 3.4 Document procedures accurately
Communicator
- Part A: COM 1.5 Apply knowledge of cultural and religious accommodations in scheduling and techniques for post-mortem exams and death investigations ensuring that the death investigation is not compromised
- Part A: COM 4.3 Communicate information appropriately, including evidence-informed opinions and conclusions, to law enforcement personnel, coroners/medical examiners, and lawyers
- Part B: COM 4.1 Adapt record keeping to the specific guidelines of Forensic Pathology and the medico-legal context
Collaborator
- Part A: COL 1.3 Provide timely and necessary written information to colleagues to enable effective relationship-centered services
Leader
- Part A: L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Professional
- Part A: P 3.1 Fulfil the requirements of the physician’s duty to report, including communicable disease and suspected child, domestic or elder abuse
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-6
Formulating reports and documenting opinions of pediatric, and complex adult cases
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the principles of histology and pathophysiology as they relate to Forensic Pathology
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the principles of the various fields of forensic sciences, including toxicology, chemistry, biology (including DNA testing), firearm and tool mark examination, entomology, forensic photography, blood pattern analysis, fingerprint analysis, trace evidence and alternative light source examinations
- ME 1.6 Describe the information and limitations pathology can provide including but not limited to time of death determination
- ME 2.5 Interpret post-mortem findings in light of the clinical history and/or scene investigation and appreciate potential limitations of such interpretations
- ME 2.5 Formulate conclusions regarding cause and mechanism and manner of death in complex and/or pediatric cases
- ME 4.1 Ensure follow-up on results of investigation and ancillary testing
Communicator
- COM 4.1 Document death investigations to support conclusion, reasoning, and the rationale for decisions and adequate detail to allow independent review
Collaborator
- COL 1.3 Provide timely and necessary written information to colleagues to enable effective relationship-centered services
Scholar
- S 3.3 Evaluate the applicability (external validity or generalizability) of evidence from a resource
Professional
- P 1.2 Demonstrate an appreciation of the limitations of findings, individual professional limits and the necessity of seeking appropriate second opinions
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-7
Facilitating organ and tissue donation
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Demonstrate awareness of relevant laws and regulations in relation to tissue/organ procurement, tissue retention, principles of consent, privacy and confidentiality
- ME 1.6 Adapt as the complexity, uncertainty, and ambiguity of the situation evolves
- ME 2.1 Determine whether organ or tissue donation will impair the forensic pathologist’s ability to provide an opinion
- ME 3.1 Integrate potential organ and/or tissue donation into death investigation procedures
Health Advocate
- HA 2.1 Contribute to a process to improve health in the communities or populations they serve
Professional
- P 2.1 Demonstrate a commitment to the promotion of the public good, including stewardship of resources
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-8
Managing multiple victim fatalities
Key features and assessment plan
- This EPA may be based on a real or simulated case
Review, by supervisor, of resident’s submission of a brief report (oral or written) applying principles of managing multiple victim fatalities to a real or simulated case Use Form 1. Collect 1 observation of achievement
Suggested observations: 1
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of principles of forensic anthropology and forensic odontology
- ME 1.3 Demonstrate understanding of elementary issues of multiple victim incidents
- ME 5.1 Prevent contamination of the death scene
- ME 2.4 Maintain the chain of evidence in multiple victim fatalities
- ME 3.2 Determine whether jurisdictional authorization applies in cases of multiple victim incidents
- ME 2.3 Establish identification, with consultation where appropriate
Communicator
- COM 2.1 Integrate, summarize, and present the information obtained from a multiple victim death investigation, including disaster victim identification (DVI) form
- COM 2.1 Seek and synthesize relevant information from other sources including the stakeholders, law enforcement personnel and medico-legal team
Collaborator
- COL 1.3 Demonstrate an interprofessional approach for death investigations (scene investigation, post-mortem examination, history, ancillary investigations)
Leader
- L 3.1 Ensure the appropriate transport of bodies in situations of multiple fatalities including consideration of storage and release of remains
Professional
- P 1.1 Manage complex issues while preserving confidentiality
- P 4.1 Integrate skills that support adaptation and recovery in challenging situations
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-9
Balancing clinical and other professional responsibilities
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.4 Act as a consultant to clinical colleagues, coroners, law enforcement personnel, judges and lawyers, on the interpretation and relevance of pathological findings
Collaborator
- COL 1.2 Consult as needed with other health care professionals, including other physicians
- COL 2.1 Delegate tasks and responsibilities in an appropriate and respectful manner
Leader
- L 2.2 Optimize practice patterns for cost-effectiveness and cost control
- L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Scholar
- S 1.2 Seek and interpret multiple sources of performance data and feedback, with guidance, to continually improve performance
- S 3.1 Generate focused questions that address practice uncertainty and knowledge gaps
- S 3.3 Evaluate the applicability (external validity or generalizability) of evidence from a resource
- S 3.4 Identify new evidence appropriate to their scope of professional practice through quality-appraised evidence-alerting services
Professional
- P 1.1 Complete assigned responsibilities
- P 2.1 Demonstrate a commitment to the promotion of the public good, including stewardship of resources
- P 2.1 Demonstrate a commitment to maintaining and enhancing competence
- P 4.2 Manage competing personal and professional priorities
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-10
Conducting peer review of cases
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Scholar
- S 1.2 Participate in peer review for purposes of personal practice improvement
Professional
- P 1.2 Demonstrate an appreciation of the limitations of findings, individual professional limits and the necessity of seeking appropriate second opinions
- P 3.3 Participate in the review of practice, standard setting and quality improvement activities
- P 3.3 Demonstrate a commitment to excellence in the discipline by participating in regular peer-review
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-11
Providing clinical supervision for technical staff and junior learners
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Scholar
- S 2.1 Use strategies for deliberate, positive role-modelling
- S 2.2 Ensure a safe learning environment for all members of the team
- S 2.3 Identify situations involving learners where the death investigation may be compromised, and manage them appropriately
- S 2.3 Supervise learners to ensure they work within limits, seeking guidance and supervision when needed
- S 2.4 Describe teaching strategies relevant to their discipline
- S 2.4 Identify the learning needs and desired learning outcomes of others
- S 2.5 Provide written or verbal feedback to other learners, faculty and other members of the team
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-12
Delivering formal teaching sessions
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Apply knowledge of the clinical and biomedical sciences as well as issues of medical jurisprudence relevant to Forensic Pathology
Scholar
- S 2.4 Define specific learning objectives for a teaching activity
- S 2.4 Identify the learning needs and desired learning outcomes of others
- S 2.4 Plan, prepare and deliver a learning activity
- S 3.3 Evaluate the applicability (external validity or generalizability) of evidence from a resource
- S 3.4 Identify new evidence appropriate to their scope of professional practice through quality-appraised evidence-alerting services
Professional
- P 1.1 Demonstrate respect for the deceased and the death investigation in publications and teaching presentations
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
C-13
Completing a scholarly activity
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Scholar
- S 4.4 Pose medically and scientifically relevant and appropriately constructed questions amenable to scholarly investigation
- S 3.3 Evaluate the applicability (external validity or generalizability) of evidence from a resource
- S 4.1 Contribute to a scholarly investigation or the dissemination of research findings in their discipline
- S 4.2 Discuss and provide examples of the ethical principles applicable to research and scholarly inquiry relevant to Forensic Pathology
- S 4.3 Actively participate as a research team member, balancing the roles and responsibilities of a researcher with the roles and responsibilities of a physician
- S 4.4 Select appropriate methods of addressing a given scholarly question
- S 4.5 Summarize and communicate the findings of applicable research and scholarly inquiry to professional and lay audiences, including stakeholders
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
Transition to Practice
TTP-1
Performing death investigations
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 2.2 Assess a death scene
- ME 3.2 Ensure appropriate legal authority is obtained for procedures
- ME 3.1 Determine the most appropriate procedures to accurately assess cause, manner and mechanism of death
- ME 2.5 Perform a complete post-mortem examination in a range of natural and unnatural deaths, with appropriate description of the external and internal findings, including gross and microscopic examinations
- ME 2.5 Identify the circumstances when toxicological and other ancillary investigations/tests may be appropriate, and apply the procedures for sampling tissues, fluids and other evidence for these additional investigations
- ME 2.5 Interpret post-mortem findings in light of the clinical history and/or scene investigation and appreciate potential limitations of such interpretations
- ME 2.6 Take or organize satisfactory external, gross and microscopic photographs of the post- mortem examination and any relevant tissues
- ME 3.3 Prioritize a procedure, taking into account potential for deterioration of evidence, and available resources
- ME 3.4 Perform procedures in a skillful and safe manner, adapting to unanticipated findings or changing circumstances
- ME 4.1 Implement a plan that supports ongoing cases, follow-up on investigations, response to stakeholder needs, and further consultation
Communicator
- COM 4.1 Document death investigations in an accurate, complete, timely and accessible manner, and in compliance with legal and privacy requirements
- COM 4.3 Communicate information appropriately, including evidence-informed opinions and conclusions, to law enforcement personnel, coroners/medical examiners, and lawyers
Collaborator
- COL 1.3 Demonstrate an interprofessional approach for a death investigation (scene investigation, post-mortem examination, history, ancillary investigations)
Leader
- L 1.2 Consistently apply the principles of laboratory safety and universal precautions
Professional
- P 1.1 Exhibit appropriate professional behaviours
- P 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-2
Organizing the daily workload of the FP unit
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 2.1 Prioritize which issues need to be addressed during death investigation or with other investigators
- ME 1.5 Carry out professional duties in the face of multiple, competing demands
- ME 1.5 Prioritize cases on the basis of case complexity
- ME 3.3 Prioritize a procedure taking into account potential for deterioration of evidence, and available resources
Communicator
- COM 1.5 Apply knowledge of cultural and religious accommodations in scheduling and techniques for post-mortem exams and death investigations ensuring that the death investigation is not compromised
Collaborator
- COL 1.2 Coordinate scheduling with external stakeholders agencies and collaborators
- COL 1.3 Demonstrate an interprofessional approach for death investigations (scene investigation, post-mortem examination, history, ancillary investigations)
- COL 2.1 Delegate tasks and responsibilities in an appropriate and respectful manner
Leader
- L 2.1 Allocate resources for optimal delivery of services
- L 3.1 Engage personnel and procedures effectively in death investigations including maintaining the legal chain of custody of evidence
Health Advocate
- HA 3.1 Fulfil and adhere to the professional and ethical codes, standards of practice, and laws governing practice
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-3
Managing the caseload of a forensic pathologist
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.1 Demonstrate a commitment to high-quality delivery of services
- ME 1.2 Integrate the CanMEDS Intrinsic Roles into their practice of Forensic Pathology
- ME 1.5 Carry out professional duties in the face of multiple, competing demands
Collaborator
- COL 1.2 Negotiate overlapping and shared responsibilities with physicians and other colleagues in medico-legal team 5 S 1.2Participate in peer review for purposes of personal practice improvement
Professional
- P 1.1 Exhibit appropriate professional behaviours
- P 1.2 Demonstrate a commitment to excellence in all aspects of practice
- P 4.2 Manage personal and professional demands for a sustainable practice throughout the Forensic Pathologist life cycle
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-4
Consulting for the criminal and civil justice system
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 1.3 Demonstrate understanding of sections of the Canadian Criminal Code relevant to Forensic Pathology
- ME 1.4 Act as a consultant to clinical colleagues, coroners, law enforcement personnel, judges, lawyers, on the interpretation and relevance of pathological findings
Communicator
- COM 4.3 Communicate information appropriately, including evidence-informed opinions and conclusions, to law enforcement personnel, coroners/medical examiners, and lawyers
Scholar
- S 3.4 Integrate best evidence and expertise into decision-making
Professional
- P 1.1 Exhibit appropriate professional behaviours
- P 1.2 Demonstrate an appreciation of the limitations of findings, individual professional limits and the necessity of seeking appropriate second opinions
- P 3.1 Demonstrate an understanding of the criminal, civil and inquest procedures, the role of the Crown and the defense, and the rules of evidence
- P 3.1 Demonstrate the legal, ethical and behavioural requirements when testifying
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-5
Managing the physical and psychological safety of staff
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Medical Expert
- ME 5.2 Adopt strategies that promote safety and address human and system factors
- ME 5.2 Demonstrate knowledge of reportable and communicable infectious diseases and determine the need for communication with the appropriate authorities
- ME 5.2 Demonstrate safe techniques for high risk autopsies
Collaborator
- COL 1.1 Establish and maintain healthy relationships with physician and other colleagues in the medico-legal team to support relationship-centered collaborative services
- COL 1.1 Anticipate, identify, and respond to safety issues related to the function of a team
Leader
- L 1.2 Apply the principles of laboratory safety and universal precautions consistently
- L 1.2 Actively encourage all involved in death investigation, regardless of their role, to report and respond to unsafe situations
Professional
- P 1.1 Exhibit appropriate professional behaviours
- P 4.3 Promote a culture that recognizes, supports, and responds effectively to colleagues in need
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-6
Developing a learning plan for first 3-5 years of practice
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Scholar
- S 1.1 Develop, implement, monitor, and revise a personal learning plan to enhance professional practice
- S 1.2 Identify opportunities for learning and improvement by regularly reflecting on and assessing their performance using various internal and external data sources
- S 2.5 Role-model regular self-assessment and feedback-seeking behaviour
- S 3.3 Critically evaluate the integrity, reliability, and applicability of medico-legal research and literature
- S 3.4 Integrate best evidence and expertise into decision-making
Professional
- P 2.1 Demonstrate a commitment to maintaining and enhancing competence
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.
TTP-7
Developing and maintaining a professional curriculum vitae
Entrustment (how much supervision did this activity need?)
- I had to do
- I had to talk them through
- I needed to prompt
- I needed to be there just in case
- I didn’t need to be there
Leader
- L 4.2 Develop and maintain a curriculum vitae with formatting and content appropriate for use in medico-legal proceedings
Case description
Feedback provided
Next steps
Copyright © 2019 The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Referenced and produced with permission.